Book Review: "The Warburgs" by Ron Chernow

2 stars
Books about wealthy Jews are unlikely to stoke the fires of passion in many people, but I became interested in the book while doing research on Jewish banker influence in America, and wanted to explore the 600+ page book to find nuggets of truth from Jewish influence in 19th-20th century Germany to bring back to the States.
It is likely Ron Chernow, the author of the book who also wrote a book on Hamilton (that became the musical Hamilton), was given permission by the Warburg estate to write this book, and so his tone throughout the book is naturally complimentary of the Warburg family, one of the “Big Four” Hamburg banking families in Germany that basically financed the Weimar Republic before Hitler and the NSDAP took over. That doesn’t mean that the information he provides on the Warburgs, particularly their correspondences on the future of Germany (which the Jewish bankers thought was going to be a “Golden Age”) isn’t interesting. I managed to read over 2/3rds of the book before finally collapsing my reading under the weight of other reading and interests, but not before I got an extensive picture of Jewish family influence in Germany, and what can be applied and not applied to the United States.
And the number one takeaway that I got from reading this book was this:
The Failure of “Lived Experience”
In the early part of the 21st century, “lived experience” narratives were dominating the mainstream, and “Woke 1.0” represented the phenomenon of “arguing from intense internal trauma,” particularly to stage a narrative where you, your race, class, gender, religion, etc. faced indelible discrimination, and so deserve certain “reparative” advantages in present-day society. Critics – such as me – countered that other minorities who also faced discrimination nevertheless persisted without complaint and earned their advantages in American society, particularly, but the “Great Awokening,” in effect, was an epoch of debate about the value of discrimination narratives.
Well, pre-WWII German society challenges all that.
As the book won’t tell you, because it is written from the perspective of an American author dyed deep in the wool of discrimination narratives, Jews became wealthy in Germany because the German people allowed it to happen. Ever since the Medieval era, Jews were recruited by the Catholic church to engineer and build certain towns, like Erfurt, Maine, and later Frankfurt, and the Church effectively turned a blind eye to Jewish rent-seeking because of their value as accountants and financiers. Extreme Jewish in-group preference allowed Jewish families to persist and consolidate resources, and by the 16th century the paradigm of early modern Jewish influence was established – concentrated in the hands of a few Jewish families, loans were approved or disapproved, wars were financed or not financed, and Jews controlled much of those large transactions.
This is not something that “examining the personal letters of Max Warburg” would tell you, because the Warburg family produced strictly contemporary creatures – they knew about the world as they saw it in their day, not as a culmination of historical scales and balances bestowed upon them. And their day was rooted in their deep hankering for their own emancipation. You see, until the 19th century, it was understood by German society that Jewish wealth and control was “checked” by ghettoing Jews – from preventing them from reaching the pinnacles of German politics and by separating them, to give German society a reprieve from their haggling demands. It is as likely Germans were okay with this arrangement for the sake of balancing society as they were due to any animus towards Jews. However, as money replaced nobility (genealogy) as the engine of capitalist society, Jews became ever more influential, and families like the Warburgs sought every privilege imaginable and previously unattainable to them. Max Warburg became the economic advisor to Kaiser Wilhelm II, Felix Warburg flitted around high society, dating multiple American opera singers at the same time, and Aby Warburg – possibly the most contemplative and prescient of the three brothers – lost his Jewish faith. All were modern privileges, borne of their “lived experience” as creatures of their own ambition.
But the hedonism disguises a fact that the 600 page book carefully elides: that the Warburgs were not very smart at all, but in fact made every wrong prediction about the world until their downfall to the Nazis. They all failed to understand how their emancipatory lens – the same lens advertised by Woke 1.0 American liberals – was not one shared by a German society that saw the scales becoming unbalanced. By using money – the conduit of their power which they attained because Germany let them – to seek political power and social control, the Warburgs alienated themselves from the delicate history of their people. Furthermore, when they made mistakes in judgment, they failed to show the proper remorse. When Max Warburg advised the Kaiser, he predicted immediate victory over the Soviet Union – partially because he hated the anti-Semitic Leninist regime. Instead, Germany lost to those Russians and Germany became the laughing stock of the world. Instead of suffering with his people, Max relied on American connections to keep his own boat afloat while his German people fell into depression. After Germany lost WWI, the Warburgs attempted to bring in the franc to stability the German currency – instead, a non-Jew named Hjalmar Schacht bet on a new German currency based on the value of German land – and the nationalist currency won, embarrassing the Warburg family as aloof non-patriots.
The Warburg predictions were colored by their experiences, for sure – particularly his experience of discrimination and his ethnicity’s fate – but that focus on his internal experience also prevented him from seeing the wider world conspiring against Germany, and he served office failing to understand the natures of the people who got him and his family here in the first place.
And that brings me to why this book inadvertently illustrates why lived experience cannot be our best lens for viewing history – because lived experience isn’t historical. Solely concentrating on your present-day emotions and your present-day resources, there is little time for reflection on how your present day resources were gained by a combination of historical endowments and political winds that represented the wisdom of other people and their appraisal of you and your condition. Such a nosedived view of your own ethnicity’s role in the world fails to consider how other people gave you the ability to think and move in that way.
And when a book by an American author turns up out of nowhere, over 600 pages long and exceedingly complimentary of the family that basically doomed Jewish influence in Europe, you have to think – has this family learned anything at all?
A Spot of Reflection
Perhaps the one Warburg who redeems himself in the long shadow of time is Aby Warburg. The most sensitive of the brothers, he was eventually diagnosed with schizophrenia, and died, after having built a library to showcase his knowledge and wisdom. But his library hosted Sigmund Freud, scholars of Rembrandt, and symbolists from East Asia to introduce far more enduring theories of the world than what Max, Paul, and Felix did with their money. For a time, Aby was Christian. He believed in regeneration from repressed fears. He believed in the nature to confront truth. He believed only in truth can society move past its scars.
In our post-Holocaust age, when those same Jews have fled to America and have already started building up their own narratives here in the States, narratives designed to protect them and shield them, the lesson here is that building castles of sand – a la, castles grounded only in self-preservation and not truth – will not help you in the long run. Aby’s search for truth represents the best Jews have to offer: unparalleled intellectual enthusiasm and sheer passion – but it’s also a warning to Jews who try to avoid the truth because of their unwillingness to see what’s on the other side. The Warburgs, ultimately, is a self-preserving document – not to say there aren’t valuable things to gain from it – and therefore, in the long eye of history, it represents what people try to do with influence and not true influence.




Comments